Best Answer

I assume your question refers to The United States in our current circumstances, i.e. the War on Terror. I come from the Cold War generation that faced a universal draft. In fact, I volunteered for the army because I knew if I didn't I'd be drafted. I served through the Cuban Missile Crisis and the Berlin Wall. I was serving when President Kennedy was shot and we weren't sure whether there was a conspiracy or if the Soviets were involved. We didn't stop the draft until 1973, just two years before we finally gave up and got out of Vietnam.

Under what circumstances might conscription be necessary? Whether you agree with the war in Iraq or not, the bottom line is that our all-volunteer military is stretched perilously thin in Iraq and Afghanistan. We have not been able to capture Osama bin Laden or any of his higher ups. The War in Iraq has nearly sucked dry the energy of all the Armed Forces. We are extending tours for our soldiers, and some of our troops have done three tours so far in either Iraq or Afghanistan, with no end in sight. The troops we have are becoming exhausted, and enlistment rates are down, especially for the army.

Despite the Pentagon's own admission that our self sacrificing volunteer troops are nearing the breaking point, the present administration is rattling the saber at both Iran and North Korea over nuclear weapons and other issues, especially the mounting evidence that Iran is providing deadly weapons and training to terrorists in Iraq. Should we somehow end up in a war with either or both, where would the soldiers come from? It's at that point that I think conscription might be necessary. It could even become necessary should enlistment rates fall to the point that we can no longer supply the troops to keep up the "surge" in Iraq, if the next administration chooses to continue the fight. If the all volunteer force is too small and depleted to do the job, history shows that the government is likely to turn to conscription. It did in the Civil War and both World Wars, not to mention The Cold War and Vietnam.

The really big question is, what happens if the government tries to reinstate the draft? How many young people would obey the law? How many would burn their draft cards or flee? Do we conscript women? Should women fight? (They do now.) Do we have to agree with a war in order to fight it? Can those who don't agree say No? These are all questions I personally hope we never have to answer.

User Avatar

Wiki User

โˆ™ 2008-12-06 17:34:29
This answer is:
User Avatar
Study guides

Politics and Government

20 cards

Who are the most important officials in the executive branch

What argument for keeping or eliminating the electoral college did you find most compelling

What is one major factor that can result in biased news stories

What are two common strategies that interest groups use to shape public policy

See all cards
3 Reviews

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Under what circumstances might conscription be necessary?
Write your answer...
Related questions

Explain under what circumstances is a business manager a business administrator?

Explain under what circumstances a business manager might also be a business administrator

Under which circumstances might the reduction of blood flow to the kidneys occur?

During masturbation.

Under what circumstances might it be hard to establish a large area of protected land?

to much money!

Under what circumstances might the president declare a country's diplomat to be persona non grata?

Suspected or found to be involved in espionage. As a retaliatory act against another nation. Any deemed necessary for security purposes.

Which condition might be resolved as a result of circumcision?

None there is no reason to be circumciced exept under extreme circumstances.

Under what circumstances might robots replace humans in space exploration?

If the heveanly body was dangerous or distant.

How do you use under in a sentence?

I put the big box under the table.She said she felt under the weather, which means she felt sick.Under other circumstances, it might have worked out well.

Is there any circumstances that cocaine might be legal?

It is used in some hospitals but is kept under double lock and key.And in pharmacies

Will friction hurt a car?

It may, under certain circumstances. For example, if you brake suddenly, the tyres might wear off quickly.

Can chocolate cause weight loss?

No, under normal circumstances, chocolate does not 'make' you lose weight. It might, however, cause you to gain weight.

Explain under what circumstances a business owner might also be a business manager?

i dont know the answer but i want to know do i get it.

Is naming a verb?

no... in some circumstances it might be

How could the Titanic have suvived?

Titanic crashed into the iceberg under circumstances where a million chance-things conspired to put her under but she was sailing under the protocol of the times so anything different might have still worked against her.

Are there circumstances where you can skip requirement engineering?

There might be circumstances where you can skip. But you should never skip the requirement engineering.

Is import the synonym for transport?

No. Import means to bring in. Transport means to carry or convey. Under some circumstances, the words might have a similar meaning, but they are not synonyms.

Can you Answer this well known proverb Under no circumstances compute the number of your barnyard fowl previous to their incubation?

Never count your chicken before they hatch. They might be ducks.

Under what set circumstances might congress decide a precidential election?

If no candidate receives a majority of the electoral votes,the house votes by state to decide the winner.

What ordinary things might be consideration in a contract?

Ordinary things which may be consideration include origins, accreditation, Eugoogleys, and conscription.

How do you use the word circumstances in a sentence?

Examples:Depending on your circumstances, you might want to rent rather than buy.The circumstances surrounding his disappearance were unusual.In his circumstances, I would have chosen to do the same thing.Considering the circumstances of the situation, we had to make a brash decision.

Are airsoft guns danggerous?

No, but, they might be dangerous in the right circumstances.

Can you get a photo id in Pennsylvania without a social security number?

If you are a US citizen, most likely not. If you are visiting from another country, you might be able to do this under special circumstances.

Why might the President use a pocket veto?

what circumstances might the president use a pocket veto

Under what circumstances does one undergo wilderness therapy?

There are many reason one might undergo wilderness therapy. The use of 'wilderness therapy' is a growing practice used to treat many different issues one might have.

Can you leave the state to get married if your on probation?

CHECK CAREFULLY. If you have travel restrictions you could be in violation if you do. On the other hand, under those circumstances, ask the court's permission for travel. You might be surprised. The judge just might permit it.

Why ovefishing is necessary?

Though some might say it is necessary to feed the population of the world, overfishing is not necessary.