answersLogoWhite

0

The No True Scotsman fallacy is when someone redefines a group to exclude individuals who do not fit their desired image. For example, if someone says, "No true Scotsman would ever do that," they are unfairly changing the definition of a "true Scotsman" to suit their argument. This fallacy can be used to avoid facing evidence that contradicts one's beliefs about a group or identity.

User Avatar

AnswerBot

1mo ago

Still curious? Ask our experts.

Chat with our AI personalities

DevinDevin
I've poured enough drinks to know that people don't always want advice—they just want to talk.
Chat with Devin
LaoLao
The path is yours to walk; I am only here to hold up a mirror.
Chat with Lao
ProfessorProfessor
I will give you the most educated answer.
Chat with Professor

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What is the No True Scotsman fallacy and how does it apply to the concept of defining a true Scotsman?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Philosophy

Example of fallacy of remote division?

An example of the fallacy of remote division would be: "Bill Gates is a very wealthy man. Bill Gates is a philanthropist. Therefore, all people who work at Microsoft must be wealthy and philanthropic." This fallacy incorrectly assumes that the attributes of the whole (Bill Gates) apply equally to its parts (all Microsoft employees).


What is the Lesson learn love is a fallacy?

The lesson in "Love is a Fallacy" is that love cannot be reduced to mere logic or rationality. The story illustrates how trying to apply logic to emotions like love can lead to an oversimplified understanding that misses the complexity and depth of human relationships. It ultimately shows that genuine connection and affection cannot be dictated by reason alone.


What are some synonyms for the word 'misconception'?

Some synonyms for the word 'misconception' include misunderstanding, fallacy, and misbelief.


How can we apply the concept of the expanding circle to the ethical dilemma of the drowning child?

The concept of the expanding circle suggests that we should extend our moral concern beyond our immediate circle to include others. In the ethical dilemma of the drowning child, applying this concept means recognizing the value of all human life and feeling a moral obligation to help, even if the child is a stranger.


How does the concept of "the more you learn, the less you know" apply to your personal experiences and understanding of the world?

The concept of "the more you learn, the less you know" suggests that as you gain knowledge, you become more aware of how much there is still to learn. In my personal experiences, the more I learn about a topic, the more I realize how complex and nuanced it is, leading me to understand that there is always more to discover and understand. This concept has humbled me and encouraged me to continue learning and exploring new ideas.